Israeli Court Limits Use of Spy Agency to Track Virus Cases

Israel's top court ruled Monday the government must curb its use of the domestic spy agency to track coronavirus infections, saying "draconian" surveillance constituted a blow to democracy.

The government began using the Shin Bet's surveillance technologies in March 2020, when Covid-19 infections began to spike.

But the supreme court quickly blocked such practice, saying legislation was needed to authorize the program.

Tracking was discontinued in June but the following month, amid another infection surge, parliament passed a law allowing the surveillance when "an epidemiological investigation cannot be completed otherwise." 

Initially approved for three weeks, that has measure has been repeatedly extended since while details of how information was obtained were kept secret.

Critics cried foul over invasion of privacy, but supporters claimed there was no civilian alternative to the Shin Bet's technologies. 

Ruling on a challenge filed by four civil society groups, a seven-judge panel said the government must significantly limit its use of the spy agency beginning March 14.

"From this day on, the use of the Shin Bet will be limited to cases in which a confirmed coronavirus patient was not cooperating in his (epidemiological) investigation, whether intentionally or not, or gave no report of his encounters," the court said.  

The justices criticized the state's protracted use of the Shin Bet in the pandemic fight, saying it gave the feeling that "every Israeli citizen and resident is under constant surveillance, as if he were a character in George Orwell's '1984' (novel)."   

"Allowing the government to use the surveillance details is a severe, exceptional and draconian blow to the right for privacy and the democratic fabric of society in Israel," the decision said. 

The ruling noted improvements in the health ministry's epidemiological investigations.

That, combined with flaws in the Shin Bet's monitoring technology, made its use more harmful than beneficial, the court said.   

The Association for Civil Rights in Israel, one of the petitioners, welcomed the ruling, which they hoped would lead authorities "to pause and change course from this slippery slope of using extreme and undemocratic means" against the pandemic. 

Deputy health minister Yoav Kisch of the ruling Likud party called the decision "a crime against the health of Israeli citizens." 

"To this day the Shin Bet's abilities saved the lives of 500 Israelis. On March 14 that will end because of the supreme court," he wrote on Twitter.