قرار بوقف بث فيلم "براءة المسلمين" في لبنان وإبلاغ كل المختصين بوجوب التنفيذ

Read this story in English W460

أصدر القاضي نديم زوين قرارا بوقف نشر فيلم "براءة المسلمين" على مواقع الإنترنت في لبنان لما يتضمنه من "إساءة كبيرة".

وأوضح مكتب المحامية مي الخنساء التي تقدّمت بدعوى أمام القضاء قبل أيام طالبت فيه بوقف نشر الفيلم، في بيانأنه بناء على الدعوى "صدر الآن قرار معجّل التنفيذ نافذاً عن أصله عن حضرة قاضي الأمور المستعجلة في بيروت نديم زوين يقضي بوقف بث فيلم براءة المسلمين".

وفي قراره قال قاضي الأمور المستعجلة في بيروت إنه بعد أن "تبيّن أن فيلم 'براءة المسلمين' يتضمن لقطات فيها إساءة كبيرة وواضحة للمستعدية"، قرر إبلاغ مواقع يوتيوب (www.youtube.com) ولايفليك (www.liveleak.com) وهوليوود ريبورتر (www.hollywoodreporter.com) وجوب وقف بث ونشر الفيلم في لبنان وكل فيلم يتضمن لقطات منه.

وطلب إبلاغ وزارة الإتصالات وشركات توزيع الإنترنت في لبنان وجوب إجراء كل ما هو لازم لوقف بث ونشر مضمون الفيلم.

وكانت المحامية الخنساء طالبت في الدعوى إنه "بما أن موقع "يو تيوب" يعرض ويروّج للفيلم المسيء للرسول، ويتم عرضه بواسطة شركات الإنترنت في لبنان"، فإنها تطالب المحكمة بـ"وقف بث الفيلم في كل وسائل الإنترنت في لبنان".

كما طالبت بـ"فرض غرامة قدرها مليون دولار يومياً على كل وسيلة تستمر ببث الفيلم".

وأثار الفيلم المسيء الذي أنتج في الولايات المتحدة الأميركية، موجة احتجاجات عارمة في العالمين العربي والإسلامي، كان أعنفها في مدينة بنغازي الليبية حيث هاجم متظاهرون غاضبون مقر القنصلية الأميركية في المدينة، مما أدّى الى مقتل السفير الأميركي كريس ستيفنز و3 أميركيين آخرين.

وفي لبنان اندلعت احتجاجات كبيرة ضد الفيلم نظمها حزب الله وحركة أمل وإمام مسجد بلال ين رباح في صيدا الشيخ أحمد الأسير، كذلك حرق مطعم "كاي إف سي" في طرابلس منذ أسبوعين وأطلق النار على فرع آخر في النبطية.

وقامت عدة دول بينها روسيا بوقف بث الفيلم على مواقع الإنترنت فيما حجبت أخرى، بينها باكستان، موقع يوتيوب الذي يبث الفيلم.

التعليقات 36
Thumb lebanon_first 20:16 ,2012 أيلول 24

stupid slow law makers. Couldnt you have made this decision earlier, spared lives, spared us the Nasrallah circus, spared the burned businesses, mostly spared the killed in tripoli. Stupid slow law makers.

Thumb lebanon_first 21:53 ,2012 أيلول 24

I understand that:
Tripoli's thugs were manipulated by some malevolent party into creating chaos.- Their move was disgusting.
Nasrallah used the film to to position and market himself as a reasonable, christian-respecting, restrained political chief, think elections 2013... His move while not disgusting, was self serving and manipulative.
so yes if you are only comparing, you are right.
However, I would like to see 100,000 chiite manifest for LEBANON for once. Not for Islam. Not against some stupid movie. Not for Assad. But for LEBANON. And we have enough causes to manifest for in our country. What about a manifestation to start drilling for oil? Or a manifestation to remove all palestinian and other illegal weapons? If they have all this energy to manifest, why not use it for something constructive?

Thumb bigsami 05:35 ,2012 أيلول 25

Schizo Farsi BSThrower....take your two cents worth elsewhere.

Missing maroun 08:27 ,2012 أيلول 25

FT hizb was not protesting the film ,but promoting themselves ..there is a difference

Thumb bigsami 16:43 ,2012 أيلول 25

Schizo as always BSThrower voting yourself UP and others down for your usual self-stimulating thrill. Moron Farsi. What do you know about freedom of speech. To you and other stone-aged conditioned sheep freedom means what your supreme leaders allow you to mutter out during all these protests/gatherings. Pathetic and regressed to say the least!

Missing samiam 21:06 ,2012 أيلول 24

how about unbanning Levi jeans instead of having to deal with Elvi's being sold in their place while you're at it?

Thumb shab 22:32 ,2012 أيلول 24

Movie for sale $100 for 15 min. Anyone`?

Thumb extramildcake 23:16 ,2012 أيلول 24

Freedom of speech. Why are we Arabs so backwards and uncivilized that we cannot understand something as simple as freedom of speech? You don't have to like what a person says, you just have to respect their right to say it!

Default-user-icon Toufic (ضيف) 02:37 ,2012 أيلول 25

Are you serious? The US and Canada banned the al-manar and other lebanese TV from showing in this part of the world on cable and/or satellite. How backward are they? Where is your freedom of speech?

Thank you.

Thumb jcamerican 12:57 ,2012 أيلول 25

Your comment was dismissed by most of the commentators here. They were distracted by their own opinions about free speech. Instead of giving you a valid answer, which there is none.

Default-user-icon Ennui (ضيف) 05:29 ,2012 أيلول 25

Don't be fooled by Freedom of Speech in America (which is what I'm assuming you are comparing to). Freedom of speech ends up being our most contested right. Any hate Speech is protected, unless it involves speech beyond the First Amendment's protection like incitement to violence (There is a a large list of restrictions of speech not protrected by the First Amendment). I feel this Movie was made for the incitement of violence to occur, not in the U.S., but in the middle east. Sad to say it will be protected in the U.S., because there will be no violence or protests because of this movie.

Thumb Sanelebanese 14:52 ,2012 أيلول 25

Have you seen " Adult swim" in the US, they make fun if Jesus wrestling with the devil. Muslim clerics on the other hand, will kill if someone plays a role of Mohammad in a movie.

Thumb bigsami 05:37 ,2012 أيلول 25

Wow Farsi BSThrower....nice of you to share with us a personal phase of your life here. Sorry this explains it all why you such a demented schizo!

Thumb lebnanfirst 07:39 ,2012 أيلول 25

Their is no such thing as half pregnant. Free speech is free speech. As soon as we start making qualitative and subjective arguments like you presented in your comment we start on a slippery slope that invites a large breach in free speech whereby anyone can claim that some speech must not be allowed because it infringes on their dignity etc. according to their interpretation.
One can feel indignant, angry or a primal urge to kill etc., one is entitled to their feelings and no one can judge based on intent and feeling. However, one cannot and must not act on those destructive feelings. If they do, they are infringing on someone else's freedom which cannot be allowed in a democracy.
In short, if one believes in free speech then one must suck it up.

Default-user-icon Zincoshine (ضيف) 13:22 ,2012 أيلول 25

If someone made a movie like that, I'd just ignore it. I'm a civilised mature grown up, unlike you and 90% of the arabs.

Thumb lebnanfirst 17:03 ,2012 أيلول 25

Your comments are a reflection on you. When it is obvious your logic holds no water you resort to insults. Typical Aouni, HA followers' attitude. How shameful.

Thumb benzona 23:47 ,2012 أيلول 24

Instead of prohibiting a stupid movie, they should prohibit dangerous rockets and other LMG that can are are being used against innocent civilians.

Default-user-icon Gregorius Bar Hebraeus (ضيف) 01:19 ,2012 أيلول 25

This movie is the most stupid film I ever seen. It´s not even a movie. It can never offense any religion due to it´s bad quality. No one should be offended by this non-film. No one would even notice it if they let it go without mention it. G-d have mercy and put some brain in peoples head so we can make good deeds and respect one another. Men habbe saret abbe.

Missing cedars 01:58 ,2012 أيلول 25

Can someone explain the benefits of Zawaj el Mot3a?

Missing allouchi 14:47 ,2012 أيلول 25

it's a legal business transaction (with some rules) for pleasure so it's all good ;)

Thumb Sanelebanese 03:22 ,2012 أيلول 25

Ask the prophet who married at least 5, the youngest was 9, for a holy cause...

Missing gabby5 03:47 ,2012 أيلول 25

I have not heard anyone say that any of the facts of the movie were incorrect. The 9 year old girl, the heavy taxation of non-believers, the Christian priest who was kicked out wrote a twisted version of the Bible, the killing and killing glorified in the koran,.....etc. I think the problem is that the truth hurts.

Default-user-icon Rolfen (ضيف) 06:28 ,2012 أيلول 25

Practically useless, since the movie is disseminated on the Internet.

Default-user-icon banning hate (ضيف) 09:17 ,2012 أيلول 25

prohibit and ban mr nasrallah who cries out with his multitudes "death to america" ... he represents his sect of over 1 million people in lebanon. this film produced in usa represent no sect but one individual of 300 million americans. such hypocrisy and evil deception here!

Default-user-icon F.O.S. (ضيف) 10:07 ,2012 أيلول 25

Absolute freedom of speach is necessary and should be preserved at all costs, even at the cost of offending people or whatever their opinion is (yes, religion is only an opinion!)

Default-user-icon Rola (ضيف) 11:12 ,2012 أيلول 25

R.i.p freedom of speech.... Welcome to Saudi Arabia... What next??? Ban YouTube and facebook???? Real smart of tjis "judge"....

Default-user-icon rola (ضيف) 11:15 ,2012 أيلول 25

RIP freedom of speech.., welcome to Saudi arabia... What next ban Youtube and facebook... Really stupid move....

Missing allouchi 14:45 ,2012 أيلول 25

Iran!!!

Missing eurybaric 12:03 ,2012 أيلول 25

Do you guys realize that someone logged in 8 times to vote up or down each comments? wow, how bored can one be? Hello, go play World of Warcraft...? (:

Thumb kanaandian 12:14 ,2012 أيلول 25

Naharnet, can you please remove that photo. It is utter blasphemy. Sheikh Assir will see to it that you are brought to justice should you decide NOT to remove it! Long live freedom of speech.

Missing mirak 12:33 ,2012 أيلول 25

R.I.P freedom of speech in Lebanon... welcome to Saudi Arabia.....
what next ban YouTube & facebook????

Missing allouchi 14:44 ,2012 أيلول 25

Iran !!!

Thumb sophia_angle 14:20 ,2012 أيلول 25

Freedom of opinion is sacred !! no banning is allowed !!! whatsoever!!! the movie it is they point of view of the maker alone...no need for this vast chaos n reactions...

Thumb Sanelebanese 14:46 ,2012 أيلول 25

This reaction and other acts aimed to defend God, is belittling God. It's like saying Allah Asghar, not Allah Akbar.

Missing fady25 16:02 ,2012 أيلول 25

ignorant fools , the movie was only made to kill the embassador in benghazi for some reason , believe it or not thats how smart and inteligent CIA are .

Default-user-icon Zincoshine (ضيف) 15:07 ,2012 أيلول 26

you're an idiot still living in the 20th century... its an amateur video. the internet is owned by us. we do what we want, the government can't orchestrate something like this.